Market / Competitor Research
A nine-block worksheet for mapping the market, understanding what customers already believe, and finding an opportunity strong enough to earn the switch.
How to use this
Fill each block for your market, in order. Under every block, four reference companies are analyzed using the same process. Two became category winners and two failed to reach comparable scale. You often won't be able to tell which from the surface-level research alone.
That's the point. Most competitors look strong when you only compare products, features, and marketing claims. Each takeaway exposes the deeper difference: how the winners understood the market, matched what customers already believed, and found an opening that the better-funded or more technically impressive company missed.
Scope
For paid or free, single-user B2C software. Not marketplaces, hardware, or B2B. Maps the competitive landscape, customer language, existing positioning, creative patterns, and open market opportunities. It does not define the ICP, brand identity, product offer, or whether the business will survive.
Market definition: rough draft
“We compete in the ________________ market, where people use ________________ to ________________.”
Draft it rough. The next blocks reveal who you actually compete with and where the market opportunity is.
Filled
Cal AI
SnapCalorie
Deepstash
Quibi
Takeaway
Market maturity
“This is a ________________ market. Customers already know ________________, have already seen ________________, and now need ________________ before choosing.”
Choose one: new, growing, mature, or saturated.
This tells you how much the market already understands and what your marketing must prove.
Market maturity
What the market needs to believe next
New
The problem needs explaining
Growing
The category is forming
Mature
Buyers compare differences
Saturated
Every claim sounds familiar
- Know
- Little about the category
- Tried
- Workarounds or nothing
- Believe
- The problem is real and worth solving
- Know
- The category and basic promise
- Tried
- Early products and alternatives
- Believe
- This approach can deliver the result
- Know
- The products, claims, and tradeoffs
- Tried
- One or more established options
- Believe
- Your difference fixes what failed before
- Know
- Nearly every promise in the market
- Tried
- Several products or substitutes
- Believe
- You are meaningfully better, with proof
Filled
Cal AI
SnapCalorie
Deepstash
Quibi
Takeaway
Competitive landscape
“Customers can choose direct competitors like ________________, indirect solutions like ________________, free solutions like ________________, or stay with the status quo by ________________.”
Map every option competing for the same customer goal, not only products that look like yours.
Filled
Cal AI
SnapCalorie
Deepstash
Quibi
Takeaway
Competitor positioning
“________________ positions itself around ________________, promising ________________ through ________________.”
Fill this in for each major competitor using what they repeatedly lead with across their website, ads, App Store listing, and organic content.
Filled
Cal AI
SnapCalorie
Deepstash
Quibi
Takeaway
Customer behavior & language
“Customers spend time on ________________, describe the problem using phrases like ________________, consume content about ________________, and trust ________________ when choosing a solution.”
Use real reviews, comments, searches, discussions, and social content. Record how customers actually behave and speak, not how marketers describe them.
Filled
Cal AI
SnapCalorie
Deepstash
Quibi
Takeaway
Competitor creatives
“Competitor creatives mainly use ________________, lead with ________________, show ________________, and use ________________ as proof.”
Study the repeated formats, hooks, angles, visuals, and proof used across competitor ads and organic content. Look for patterns, not individual ads.
Creative anatomy
Break down what the ad is actually doing
Format
UGC · demo · comparison · testimonial
Hook
The exact first line or opening promise
Angle
Problem · desire · identity · objection
First visual
What the viewer sees before sound matters
Product demo
The moment the product earns the claim
Proof
Result · review · metric · transformation
Analyze from the outside in. Format gets attention into the structure; proof is the innermost layer that makes the promise believable.
Filled
Cal AI
SnapCalorie
Deepstash
Quibi
Takeaway
Market patterns
“Across the market, most companies promise ________________, lead with ________________, prove it using ________________, and rarely address ________________.”
Combine what you found across competitors. Identify the promises, messages, visuals, mechanisms, and proof that repeatedly appear throughout the market.
Filled
Cal AI
SnapCalorie
Deepstash
Quibi
Takeaway
Gaps and opportunities
“Competitors focus heavily on ________________, while customers still struggle with ________________. This creates an opportunity to position around ________________ and prove it through ________________.”
A gap is only an opportunity if customers care about it, existing solutions fail to address it, and your product can prove that it solves it.
Filled
Cal AI
SnapCalorie
Deepstash
Quibi
Takeaway
Locked market brief
“We compete in the ________________ market, which is currently ________________. Customers choose between ________________. Competitors mainly position around ________________, while customers talk about and behave like ________________. Most creatives repeat ________________. The strongest open opportunity is ________________, proven through ________________.”
Combine the previous blocks into one market brief. Do not introduce new conclusions here.
This is the market document you give to AI alongside the ICP, brand, and product offers documents.
Filled
Cal AI
SnapCalorie
Deepstash
Quibi
Takeaway
Verdict: how the four sorted
Hard pass
- Cal AI ✅ — Found the gap between knowing calorie tracking works and being able to maintain it. Positioned around effortlessness and proved it immediately.
- Deepstash ✅ — Recognized that it competed against free social feeds, not only learning apps. Turned an existing scrolling behavior into productive screen time.
The instructive losses
- SnapCalorie ❌ — Found a real accuracy gap but treated measurement error as the main market problem. Most customers abandoned tracking entirely.
- Quibi ❌ — Confused an unoccupied position with meaningful demand. Customers already had abundant free entertainment for short breaks.
| Opportunity test | Result |
|---|---|
| Important problem + weak solutions + clear proof | Strong opportunity · Cal AI |
| Important desire + existing behavior + natural product fit | Strong opportunity · Deepstash |
| Real problem + narrow importance + strong proof | Viable niche · SnapCalorie |
| Open position + weak demand + strong alternatives | False gap · Quibi |
Market verdict
Winners and instructive losses
Turned an existing scrolling behavior into productive screen time.
Deepstash
Found the real gap: consistency, not more calorie information.
Cal AI
Solved accuracy, but not why most customers abandon tracking.
SnapCalorie
Found an open position without meaningful customer demand.
Quibi
Takeaway
Filled example
What a completed worksheet looks like when every block is answered.
Market research worksheet · filled
Cal AI.html · saved locally
Market research worksheet · filled
Cal AI
AI calorie tracking · consumer health / weight loss
Filled this in as a reference example so you can see what a completed market brief looks like.
1. Market definition
We compete in the weight-loss market, where people use calorie-tracking tools to manage their food intake and lose weight.
2. Market maturity
This is a mature market. Customers already know calorie tracking can help with weight loss and now need proof that a new tracker is easier to use consistently. The market needs a reason to believe this product fixes why previous trackers were abandoned.
3. Competitive landscape
Direct: MyFitnessPal, SnapCalorie, Lose It!, and YAZIO. Indirect: meal plans, coaching, nutritionists, and diet programs. Free: labels, databases, spreadsheets, notes, and manual estimation. Status quo: guessing intake without tracking consistently.
4. Competitor positioning
The occupied positions are complete tracking (MyFitnessPal), nutritional accuracy (SnapCalorie), and simple weight loss (Lose It!).
5. Customer behavior & language
Customers spend time on TikTok, Instagram, YouTube, Reddit, and fitness communities. They say “stay in a calorie deficit,” “hit my protein,” “track my macros,” “I always forget to log,” and “logging food takes forever.” They trust visible demonstrations, relatable creators, believable progress, reviews, and realistic results.
6. Competitor creatives
Competitors use UGC, screen recordings, meal-scanning demos, app comparisons, and weight-loss stories. They lead with easier logging, speed, weight loss, macros, accuracy, and meal scanning, then use product results, transformations, ratings, testimonials, comparisons, and user counts as proof.
7. Market patterns
Most companies promise easier, faster, more accurate tracking. They prove it with meal scans, calorie results, transformations, ratings, and app demos. Few address why people stop tracking after the first few days or weeks.
8. Gaps and opportunities
Competitors focus on food databases, nutritional detail, and estimate accuracy while customers struggle with consistency. The opportunity is effortless tracking for people who repeatedly quit, proven through real meals logged from photos and repeated use beyond the first scan.
9. Locked market brief
We compete in the mature weight-loss market. Customers choose trackers, meal plans, coaching, free nutrition tools, or estimation. Competitors own complete tracking, accuracy, and simple weight loss; customers talk about deficits, macros, guessing portions, and logging friction. The open opportunity is effortless tracking for people who usually quit, proven through real photo logging and repeated use.
Verdict: hard pass. The opportunity is tied to an important unresolved problem: people do not fail calorie tracking because they lack calorie information. They fail because logging becomes too tedious to maintain. Cal AI can prove its answer immediately by showing one photo replacing the manual process.
Completed example · Cal AI. For reference, don't edit this one.
Grade your sheet
Paste your completed worksheet into this prompt. The grader scores every block, audits the evidence, tests the opportunity, checks contradictions and document boundaries, then asks one hard question at a time.
Market research grading prompt
You are grading a market and competitor research worksheet for a consumer software product. You are a demanding paid-acquisition strategist, not an encouraging coach. Your job is to find weak research, unsupported assumptions, and false market opportunities before they produce generic or expensive ads. Do not compliment the work. Do not soften your findings. If an answer is generic, unsupported, or based on guessing, say so plainly. Below is a completed worksheet. Grade each block against the rules for that block. BLOCK RULES Block 1: Market definition Must define the market around what customers are trying to accomplish, not the product's technology, format, features, or App Store category. "AI apps," "health apps," and "productivity software" are industries or product labels, not useful market definitions. The definition must be broad enough to include different ways of achieving the same goal, but narrow enough that the solutions compete for the same demand. Ask whether a completely different-looking solution that helps customers achieve the same goal would be included. Block 2: Market maturity Must correctly classify the market as new, growing, mature, or saturated. Explain what customers already understand, what solutions or promises they have seen, and what they now need to believe before choosing. Do not accept a maturity label without evidence. A market is not new because the product uses new technology. Block 3: Competitive landscape Must include direct competitors, indirect solutions, free solutions, and the status quo. Direct competitors solve the same problem similarly. Indirect solutions pursue the same outcome differently. Free solutions address the goal without payment. The status quo is what customers continue doing if they do not switch. Flag options in the wrong category. The landscape fails if it only lists similar products. Block 4: Competitor positioning Must analyze how major competitors actually position themselves in public. Each answer must identify the central position, main promise, and mechanism. Positioning must come from repeated messaging across websites, ads, App Store listings, and organic content. Do not accept feature lists, one-off headlines, or personal interpretation as proven positioning. Flag crowded positions. Block 5: Customer behavior and language Must be based on real reviews, comments, discussions, searches, and social content. Identify where customers spend time, how they naturally describe the problem, what related content they consume, and what proof they trust. Generic phrases fail unless customers repeatedly use them. Platforms cannot be guessed from demographics. Flag marketing language presented as customer language. Block 6: Competitor creatives Must analyze a meaningful sample of competitor ads and organic creatives. Identify repeated formats, hooks and angles, opening visuals, product demonstrations, and proof. A list of creative ideas fails. This block is about what competitors currently use. Separate required category proof from repetitive creative elements. Block 7: Market patterns Must combine findings across several competitors. Identify repeated promises, hooks, standard visuals, expected proof, and customer concerns the market rarely addresses. A pattern must appear repeatedly. Distinguish table stakes from differentiation. Block 8: Gaps and opportunities This is the most important block. A valid opportunity must pass four tests: customers care about the unresolved problem; it appears repeatedly in customer evidence; existing solutions fail to address it; and the product can visibly prove a better answer. An empty position is not automatically an opportunity. Reject gaps based only on missing features, new formats, technical superiority, or no competitor claiming them. Test whether it gives customers a strong reason to switch from direct, indirect, free, and status quo options. Block 9: Locked market brief Must combine blocks 1 through 8 without introducing new conclusions. It must contain the market definition, maturity, competitive landscape, occupied positions, customer behavior and language, repeated creative patterns, strongest supported opportunity, and proof required. Flag statements absent from earlier research. It must not define the ICP, brand identity, or product offer. OUTPUT, IN THIS ORDER 1. Give every block a score out of 5. For every score, write one sentence naming the most important weakness. A block gets a 5 only when it is specific, supported, and defensible. 2. Complete an evidence audit. Place every important conclusion into one category: Observed: directly supported by current public evidence. Repeated: appears independently across at least three relevant customer or competitor sources. Inferred: a reasonable interpretation, but not directly proven. Unsupported: no evidence was provided. 3. Give the opportunity verdict. Choose one: Strong opportunity: important customer problem, weak existing solution, and clear product proof. Viable niche: real problem and strong proof, but limited importance or audience size. False gap: open position, but weak evidence of customer demand or strong existing alternatives. Insufficient research: not enough evidence to determine whether the opportunity is real. Explain the verdict in no more than four sentences. 4. Name the single weakest block and explain why improving it would change the final market brief the most. 5. Run a contradiction check. Identify any place where the market definition excludes mapped alternatives, maturity conflicts with customer knowledge, positioning conflicts with competitor messaging, customer language sounds like company copy, creative patterns lack support, the opportunity does not follow from the customer problem, or the locked brief introduces new conclusions. 6. Run a document-boundary check. Flag anything that belongs in another document: ICP document: specific customer, personal trigger, desired outcome, or identity. Brand document: brand voice, visual identity, personality, or communication rules. Product offers document: pricing, packaging, trials, discounts, guarantees, bonuses, or calls to action. 7. Then stop and ask me ONE question aimed at the weakest block. Wait for my answer before asking the next question. Continue one question at a time until that block would score a 4 or 5, then move to the next weakest block. Do not rewrite my answers for me. Ask questions that force me to find better evidence and write a stronger answer myself. If I give you an unsupported answer, ask for the source. If I give you a vague answer, say it is vague and ask again. Here is my completed worksheet: [PASTE YOUR SHEET HERE]